Recent
News and Happenings at Four Season Fly Fishing Guide Service
***UPDATE
FOR 1/24/12***
I watch the weather
during the months of January and February for an extended warming period
and then make plans to fish steelhead in the Erie area. I call or email
one of my fishing buddies in that area to double check that fishing
is a possibility with some open water available. The following is an
overview of such a recent contact.
This information was provided
by one of those fishing acquaintances that log a respectable number
of winter hours fishing for steelhead on 20 Mile, Elk and Walnut Creeks.
He notes that until yesterday (January 13, 2012) the tributaries were
all open and running freely. They had some snow but it all melted and
fishing has been good. That particular Thursday night the cold front
came through and the temperature dropped from 43 to 17 degrees over
night and it started snowing. It snowed all night and all the following
day. He said the slush was so thick on Elk Creek that the water was
the consistency of a Slushy. He decided to go to the mouth of Walnut
Creek, which was a little better, and managed to catch one starving
fish. This was no small miracle since both his egg and nymph dropper
were little ice cubes. His line, leader and indicator were of course
coated with ice. The temp was 21. He normally does not go fishing when
it is 20 degrees or colder. Hey, 21 degrees, well that's doable. He
did not have any digital photos to send me but his description of the
recent fishing event is more than ample. It is supposed to reach 40
degrees this week in the Erie area and if it does the streams may open
for a day or two and you can bet that he will be out there steelhead
fishing.
Just a quick note on flies that
he has been having success with recently on the steelhead tributaries.
The purple fly, as noted in a previous update, is holding it's own and
it now has a companion fly in blue. According to my fishing buddy, all
this proves almost nothing except that steelhead do not have very discriminating
taste. Another fishing buddy of mine notes that almost all trout that
he has caught on blue eggs have been rainbows/steelhead. Thinking back
to his spin fishing days, he used to do well with silver Fjord or Little
Cleo spoons with a blue stripe along the margin. He doesn't remember
any other trout species going wild over blue. He also points out that
two theories are at work here:
1) Rainbow trout like blue. 2) Show the fish something they have not
seen before.
Another fishing buddy, who lives
in Virginia, says his steelhead fishing is pretty much over until the
spring run begins. However, he was having success in December with a
pattern found on one of the Erie websites. It is a simple tie and was
successful. Basically it has a brown biot tail, Hare's Ear dubbing and
a brass, gold, or pearlescent bead. He ties it on a TMC 2457 hook in
sizes 12, 14 and 16. Oh, to tie the blue fly mentioned above, wrap purple
chenille around a scud hook and tie in a collar of blue palmer chenille,
usually one turn does it. Sometimes a glass bead (white or dark) is
added, sometimes not. You can use dubbing instead of chenille.
There is definitely winter fishing
to be had for the hearty individual. The weather in the Cumberland Valley
area hasn't been overly prohibitive when it comes to fishing. However,
if your winter fishing plans include a trip to the Erie tributaries
for steelhead fishing, do your homework ahead of time because the weather
in that area can be brutal.
***UPDATE
FOR 12/29/11***
The combination deer hunting/steelhead
fishing trip to the Erie area the second week of December was interesting.
First, my fishing buddy from that area had an outstanding day of steelhead
fishing using a nickel Cyclops style bead on a size 16 hook dubbed with
purple Antron. Nothing fancy, but productive. He dropped a small Glo
Bug, which is usually successful, off of the purple fly but it was the
purple fly that received the action. However, all the action was the
day prior to my arrival. The next day on 20 Mile Creek, after his better
than average day (you know the saying, you should have been here yesterday!),
I caught and released a few steelhead on the Royce Shiner. See Fly of
the Week Number 64. My fishing buddy also caught steelhead on the Royce
Shiner, but only one on the purple nymph. A weather front was moving
into the area and that condition may have altered the steelhead activity.
I wanted to end the day deer hunting during the regular season in New
York. So after steelhead fishing from about 10:30 to 2:30, I returned
to camp, as the clouds gathered. The drive from 20 Mile Creek to camp
was a short one. The weather front hit about an hour later as I was
in a tree stand overlooking the edge of a forested thicket with some
scattered wet lands and watching two bucks approach. The snowflakes
were quarter size, and even at the age of 68, I gazed nostalgiclly as
the large flakes drifted down. It conjured up images of the upcoming
Christmas season in my mind. The bucks moved slowly in my direction
and separated well within shooting range with the smaller of the two
(antler wise) stepping into a small clearing. Visibility was lessening
and the larger buck seemed to be content foraging for crabapples on
the forest floor. Besides, the under story between the canopy and forest
floor was more or less a netting cover of various size limbs that presented
a dicey shot. Decision time! I brought the rifle up, finding the heart
and confidently pulled the trigger. The four point buck (NY has no point
restriction system) dropped immediately in the little clearing. Now
the work began as I field dressed the critter and hauled it to camp.
Processing of the deer would take place after returning home. I now
had two solid days to concentrate on steelhead fishing with a fellow
worker who is also retired.
Bruce and I were PA State Park
Managers for a total of 77combined years of service. I retired before
Bruce and now that he has retired, fly fishing is steadily becoming
a passion with him. Bruce was one of the lucky ones that took the fly
fishing course offered by Penn State University and taught by none other
than George Harvey. Harvesting the buck mentioned above now allowed
more time to fish the next day when Bruce was scheduled to arrive. We
met in the PFBC parking lot off of Route 5 at 20 Mile Creek at 10:00
AM. The lake front snow storm had dropped the morning temperature to
15 degrees F. with only a few inches of snow close to the lake. A few
steelhead were in the stream from the Route 5 bridge down to the lake
so we drove to the parking access on upper Middle Road. The snow mixed
with ice on the trail leading into the gulf made footing treacherous
and several times we slipped on our way to 20 Mile Creek. I mention
the difficulty that can be encountered when steelhead fishing in December
and later months because of the weather, so use good judgment when planning
a trip because some of the access areas can be challenging. Bruce caught
a good size steelhead while learning a section of 20 Mile Creek for
future fishing trips and as I took several digital photos of the event,
Bruce was looking proud. While on the job as a state park manager, Bruce
has always been exceptionally willing to take on new assignments as
an opportunity for growth and I could see that same approach/commitment
as he broadened his fly fishing skills.
So let's fast forward to the
end of the day and our climb out of the gulf to the access point where
we left our vehicles. We were unprepared for the gut wrenching sight
we were to encounter that does not promote harmony and teamwork toward
anglers and landowners. It was after dark when we arrived at our vehicles
and only one of the nine other vehicles that was present when we first
arrived earlier in the day was still there. The other vehicle was a
pickup truck parked about thirty yards or so from us. I paid no attention
to the two individuals that moved about the vehicle because it was cold
and I wanted to get my wading shoes off my feet before the laces froze.
Those of you that have fished for steelhead in the winter know that
upon leaving the water in subfreezing weather, wet wading shoelaces
can freeze in a hurry. On occasion, I have spent time with my wading
shoes on in front of the vehicle heater thawing out the laces. While
removing my wading shoes and putting other fishing gear away, the pickup
truck in front of my truck pulled away from the road berm parking. Bruce
and I planned to meet here in the morning for fishing. I got into my
pickup and as I put on my headlights, I noticed a pile of steelhead
remains where the previous pickup truck had been parked. Unbelievable!
The general regulations noted in the Pennsylvania Fishing Summary regarding
field dressing and disposal of fish is specific and leaving fish remains
on the side of the road, which happened to be at a farmer's field, is
illegal. The next morning Bruce and I collected and properly disposed
of the steelhead carcasses and parts thereof. I mention this because
many good access areas are being closed to fisherman by landowners for
this very reason. There are unfortunately those individuals out there
who call themselves sportsmen but have no respect or regard for others.
***UPDATE
FOR 12/13/11***
On the return trip
home from a multiple day deer hunting adventure at our family cabin
in the Moshannon State Forest near Snowshoe, PA, my plans were to fish
the recently opened Spring Creek Canyon Cooperative Management Area
near State College. Spring Creek is known as one of the best wild brown
trout streams in Pennsylvania. Typical of other limestone waters in
Pennsylvania and elsewhere, limestone springs keep the water cool in
the warmer months and warmer in the colder months. Big plus for those
fly fishers that fish four seasons like I do. If you want to experience
unique fly fishing in the winter, visit one of the many limestone streams
that offer a special regulation catch and release section. For more
information visit www.fishandboat.com. Spring Creek is listed as a Class
A Wild Trout Water and, as expected, the trout caught (if you are knowledgeable
and perhaps lucky) are WILD! The bend in the fly rod and reluctance
of the critter on the end of the fly line to come to hand will attest
to just how feisty these wild trout tend to be. Between the Catch and
Release-Fly-Fishing Only, and Catch and Release-All Tackle Areas, one
can fish approximately 17.3 miles of prime wild trout water on Spring
Creek.
So, how did the Canyon area open
to general public access? Visit www.SpringCreekCanyon.com for interesting
reading and splendid photographs. Importantly, the end result of the
acquisition and partnership of the ~1,827 acres is the protection of
the land and water from development and the valuable access for public
passive recreation such as hiking, biking, jogging, even cross country
skiing when it snows. Somehow the fly fishing activity remains one of
my favorite "passive" recreational activities. Although, at
times I return to my vehicle a sweat ball or in the colder months frozen
to the core. So much for passive recreation! Add the benefits of conservation
and environmental education that the area offers and it is a huge win-win
package for the public.
When I arrived at the parking
lot and trail entrance to the Canyon area and was preparing for a morning
of fishing, a fly fisher pulled in next to my vehicle. We exchanged
the necessary pleasantries and I could tell he was not in a hurry to
fish. He was retired and fished Spring Creek several days a week. Also,
he was knowledgeable of the Canyon area. He felt the newly opened area
spread out the anglers and that was a huge benefit. What surprised me
was that he concentrated on fishing the water immediately downstream
of the Benner Spring Fish Hatchery area and rarely ventured into the
Canyon. His theory was the larger fish were nearer the hatchery thus
reaping the benefit of nutrients that exited the hatchery. He was a
trophy fly fisher and the catching and releasing of large trout was
his game. The other hatchery on Spring Creek at Fisherman's Paradise
provided similar opportunities for large fish. However, he stated that
having the large fish nearer the hatcheries was short lived because
the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission (PFBC) made major renovations
in the past year or so to both hatcheries. According to PFBC information,
micro-screen filtration systems and water re-circulation systems were
installed to lessen or prevent effluent water from leaving the hatcheries
and entering Spring Creek. This will result in improved water quality
in Spring Creek, end welfare for a few big trout and support an even
better wild trout population. The hatcheries are operating under restrictions
in the poundage of trout they produce because of the pollution they
were causing. These changes should allow the PFBC to produce more and
larger trout for stocking. We parted company as I headed downstream
to check out some of the water that I had not before fished. It was
difficult passing some of my favorite spots that I had fished for many
years but new territory was beckoning. The image of fishing water that
was not open to the general public since about 1912, when the Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania started purchasing land surrounding Spring Creek, was
foremost in my mind. As the first cast lightly settled on the water,
and the tandem offering of Mini Money Flies slowly descended into the
milky colored water, I thought, "Good job all you cooperative management
folks". Now it was time to catch a few Canyon Wild Trout!
***UPDATE
FOR 11/2/11***
The Pennsylvania
Fish and Boat Commission (PFBC) parking lot at Twenty Mile Creek near
the Route 5 Bridge was near parking capacity when I arrived. A quick
read told me that the steelhead were in the tributary from the mouth
of Lake Erie to the Route 5 Bridge. Why? Because on my drive to the
PFBC parking lot, no cars were parked along Middle Road that parallels
portions of Twenty Mile Creek from Route 5 to Route 20. It looked like
the same ol' same ol' as past years in early October
..too many
anglers and not enough steelhead upstream to spread the fishing pressure.
I left the area and went back to camp to prepare for the upcoming New
York archery season. Fortunately, the drive was only eight miles to
reach camp. The next day I met a fishing buddy that lives in the Erie
area and he suggested we venture upstream from the parking lot at Twenty
Mile Creek. It turned out that his game plan was a winner as several
pods of steelhead had moved higher up stream that evening and night.
We were below the I-90 Bridge and the fishing was exceptional. Now,
let me make this clear that the area we were fishing required physical
stamina to access the stream. Thousands of years of erosion created
cliffs over 200 hundred feet high and access to the stream is limited
due to the posting of property and, when not posted, swales that can
tear the best quality waders while the angler is stumbling and hand
picking his way to the stream. Waders intact, we reached the stream
and were greeted with a pod of steelhead in the first pool. See Fly
of the Week for the fly that provided the Catch and Release for a dozen
or more steelhead. The Eyebrow Streamer #59 and Emerald Shiner #49 also
contributed to the number of steelhead caught and released.
***UPDATE
FOR 7/12/11***
A wetter than normal
spring set records in April and May. The combined total of 14.8 inches
of precipitation in April and May sent the majority of our trout streams
into flood or bank top conditions. This unfortunate condition not only
hit the Cumberland Valley
but the many sections of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. Needless
to say, streams like Penns Creek, Pine Creek, Spring Creek and Yellow
Creek ran high keeping anglers off the waters and raising havoc with
the bugs that inhabit the creek bottoms. The Hendricksons and Grannoms
that appeared in late March and early April did hit a brief window of
opportunity to hatch as the big rain event in March was the 10th and
11th and the second big rain event in April was the 16th and 17th. The
rain event in April deposited 5 inches of rain in a 24 hour period that
resulted in the third highest water level (14.75 feet, registered at
the USGS
Camp Hill gage) in the Yellow Breeches since Tropical Storm Agnes
in 1972. The mid point between the two major flood events saw the Yellow
Breeches at a tolerable wading level and the appearance of the Hendrickson
and Grannom roll over hatches. Good stuff, since many fly fishers were
eager to return to the waters. However, as mentioned above, the record
precipitation and resulting near bank top water limited the opportunity
to fish and, most importantly, may have had a drastic impact on follow
up hatches such as the Caddis and Sulphurs and the upcoming Hexagenia
and White Fly, due to severe stream bottom scouring. The spring of 2011
was not your normal break away from the winter blues to get outdoors
fly fishing. The fly fishers were daunted and so were the macro-invertebrates
that trout feed upon under normal spring conditions.
One hatch that appeared in good
numbers after the devastating rain events was the Slate Winged Mahogany
Dun. Some of the common names fly fishers apply to this bug are Blue
Dun, Blue Quill (probably the most common), Summer Quill and Iron Blue
Dun. The second hatch, the Cornuta, a species of the Blue-Winged Olive,
also appeared in good numbers on Penns
Creek and I was told the Little
Juniata River. First, let's look at the Slate Winged Mahogany Dun,
examine its positive values to the fly fishers and try to bump this
bug up a notch or two on the fly fishing hatch charts. I'll cover the
Cornuta in a follow-up website update.
The first question asked of me
is what color is mahogany? The abdomen and thorax color of the Slate
Winged Mahogany Dun resembles dark-colored hardwood. More specifically,
check your house, a friend or a relative's house, for instance your
grandparents, for mahogany furniture and you will grasp the color of
the small, size 18-20 dun insect. As with genuine mahogany hardwood,
the Slate Winged Mahogany Dun is a quality insect that is worth your
effort to duplicate and fish with them. The Slate Winged Mahogany Dun
is slightly larger than the Trico and can be found on many streams from
May to September. However, unlike the Trico that appears at first light
and vanishes about mid morning, the Slate Winged Mahogany Dun can be
seen undulating in a near straight up and down line from about 10:30
AM to noon and then again toward evening. These spinners are the result
of emergence that took place a few days prior. I have followed the Mahogany
Dun action on streams like Yellow Creek and the Yellow Breeches and
even on a medium size freestone stream high on a plateau many miles
west of State College. I
have been frustrated with the airborne critters as they lower to the
water's surface and only a few trout seem to notice when they finally
spin out. Another frustrating factor occurs with the spinners. Depending
on the air temperature which varies from May to September, the spinners
may spin out any time from about noon to early evening. May, June and
early July the spinners can be seen just prior to noon and again in
the evening. Hot Summer temperatures downgrade the spinner appearances
to the evening, while the Fall temperatures bump up the appearances
from late morning to late afternoon. The spinner fall usually occurs
over riffles, pocket water and heads of pools. I now concentrate on
subsurface fishing when the emergers are active from about 9:00 AM to
about noon. I have observed that one section of a popular spot on Yellow
Creek has a combo of vegetation cover and backwater which is particularly
difficult to fish subsurface or surface because of the fast flowing
currents that are jettisoned from a thirty foot narrow chute formed
by a high ledge on one side and large boulders on the opposite side.
No easy midstream, minimal current hatching for these bugs! Why is the
spot popular? Because the water softens about half way through the 200
foot glide and fish tend to stack awaiting the arrival of food. Now
let's look at the tough spot in this popular glide that the majority
of fly fishers shun. A good portion of the food does not reach the stacked
fish because of the recycling effect in the backwater, therefore those
fish that work the backwater eat hearty and those fly fishers that are
very good at casting a distance and mending fly lines over several current
speeds do well. The rest of us watch our lines go sweeping by, dragging
the fly in tow, counter-acting what any sane trout would recognize as
potential food. Remember, fishing to the emerging duns is best done
with a dead-drift slightly below or in the surface film. See Fly of
the Week for the emerger pattern. Overall, these bugs tend to prefer
fast water for hatching and then later, they lay their eggs over fast
water. So tuck this information away for future reference and perhaps
you will be successful fishing the Slate Winged Mahogany Dun hatch.
***UPDATE
FOR 4/28/11***
The harbinger of
spring hatches arrived on March 26 in the Cumberland Valley, specifically
on the Yellow Breeches. It was a Saturday afternoon and I was completing
a carpentry project in the house. On one of my trips out to the garage
to get materials, I heard a fish splash the surface in the nearby Yellow
Breeches Creek. I tried to ignore the surface disturbance because I
wanted to complete the home improvement project. But, on the way back
to the house, I heard another splash. This one got my attention and
I ventured to the nearby water. After a few minutes another fish splashed
the surface and I saw the reason for these water disturbances
Hendricksons
floating high on the water surface! I immediately placed the home improvement
project on hold and slipped into my waders. One of the benefits of living
close to the stream is the ability to drop what one is doing at the
house and go fishing when it is warranted. I often think what a great
fly fishing clubhouse location this property would make for a group
of flyfishers that want to get away from the corporate world and have
easy access to great fishing on the renowned Yellow Breeches.
Previously, I sorted my spring
hatch flies into several fly boxes and knew exactly which fly box to
put in the chest pack. The Hendrickson fly which is number 15 and the
Red Quill, number 17, are on the Fly of the Week link of this website.
Both caught fish when the appropriate Hendrickson (female) or Red Quill
(male) flies were used. But it was the March Brown Flymph, number 42,
that provided consistent results. The flymph was fished on the surface
when a fish was observed taking duns and when the surface action was
dormant the flymph pulled under the water produced good results. If
you have been following my updates, you know the March Brown Flymph
has been productive for me on Pine Creek in the Slate Run area for the
last two years. Interesting that the flymph works well on large mayfly
bugs in late March and early April. And like the Money Fly, number 54,
the Flymph is another Cover it All (CIA) fly that catches fish whenever
mayfly hatches are on. I called the local fly shop to pass on the good
news of the appearance of the Hendricksons. However, the cold and then
cool weather slowed the Hendrickson hatches and as a result, every three
to four days, the hatch appeared in mid afternoon and lasted to about
5:00 PM. Then on April 2, the Grannoms appeared mid morning and increased
in numbers with fish aggressively taking them off the surface. Mid afternoon
the rollover hatch phenomenon of Hendricksons and Grannoms combined
to drive the trout into a feeding frenzy. Gratefully I was in the middle
of the rollover hatch activity and showed great poise under pressure,
adjusting promptly and calmly to the change. I remained in solid control
and caught fish. Talk about demonstrating coolness under stress! The
rollover hatch continued to April 15th when a huge rain event blitzed
the Cumberland Valley with five plus inches of rain in a short period
of time sending the Yellow Breeches into the highest level that I have
seen in the past seventeen years that Gayle and I have lived here. Results
another
21 inches of water in the lower level of our house. Fortunately, we
had been through floods before and have a system of recovery in place
that puts us back in control of our life style in a matter of days.
The rains continued on and off for the next week and the Yellow Breeches
remained in a condition of over the top or at the top of the bank hampering
any fishing attempts. The Hendricksons and Grannoms simply made their
departure for the season with out undue harassment.
Now, back to the fishing prior
to the disruptive high water. The flymph and Hendrickson are well documented
on the Fly of the Week link but the Grannom needs an update. I will
not go into the life cycle of the Grannom caddis but will relate to
you what Grannom fly patterns worked for me. The Grannom flies that
I used with satisfying results were the Emerger, Adult and Egg Laying
Versions. The adult Grannom, number 16, is straight forward, meaning
see the splash and place the adult fly pattern nearby and the result
is usually a hookup. The Emerger and Egg Layer fly patterns offer more
of a challenge and thus get my vote for exciting spring fishing. See
Fly of the Week for details. Looking forward to seeing you on the stream!
***UPDATE
FOR 10/11/10***
The 10 day weather forecast called
for several days of significant rain and then intermittent showers in
the Erie area. The significant rain was received and showers were to
follow on the days our CVTU Chapter members would be fishing for steelhead.
The stage was set for some good fishing, so we thought. The significant
rain permitted the steelhead that had been bumping at the shale barrier
dams, formed at the mouth of the tributaries, from Lake Erie wave action,
to move upstream into the tributaries. Anxious steelhead fishers look
for a major rain event in early October to send sufficient water down
the tributaries to break through the shale dam obstacles that prevent
steelhead from entering the tributaries for their journey upstream for
spawning purposes. That event was unfolding with help from a tropical
storm off the east coast. We were on our way to Erie!
The plan was to arrive the Quality
Inn located at 6467 Sterrettania Drive, Fairview, PA (814.838.7647)
at 1:00 PM, check in, have lunch and go fishing. We would fish the nearby
Elk Creek the remainder of the day and the following day, fish the Mile
Creeks on the East side of Erie. Upon our arrival at the Quality Inn
we learned that Elk Creek, the largest of the Lake Erie tributaries
in the Erie area, was up and off-color. However, we learned (cell phones
have improved the communication amongst fishers) that Twelve Mile Creek,
Sixteen Mile Creek and Twenty Mile Creek were in better shape and decided
to forgo fishing Elk Creek and fish the Mile Creeks on the East side
of Erie. The showers forecast for that day turned into a steady rain,
heavy at times, and the water levels at Sixteen Mile and Twenty Mile
Creeks were on the rise. Our group of ten fishers split into two groups
with Tony Dranzo directing one group and me directing the other group.
Tonys group fished Sixteen Mile Creek below the Freeport Restaurant
near Route 5 and then moved on to Twenty Mile Creek. My group remained
on the middle stretch of Sixteen Mile Creek between the Freeport Restaurant
and the Three Falls area. The visibility into the water was becoming
poorer as the afternoon unfolded. The rain continued to come down hard.
Jim Ritter of my group was the first to hook into a steelhead. Pictures
were taken and the steelhead released. Phil Snyder then hooked in to
a steelhead and during the maddening dash, the steelhead managed to
free itself from the wooly bugger. Examination of the tippet material
showed the pig tailed curl of a knot that failed. Sorry Phil, but we
have all experienced that fate at one time or another while fishing.
It happens to all of us! I eased into the water and was fishing between
Phil and Jim when a steelhead took my wooly bugger with gusto and the
fight was on! The steelhead tore downstream came up and thrashed the
surface within reaching distance of Jim Ritter. Unfortunately during
the foray in front of Jim, the hook released from the fishs mouth.
Jim with his raincoat hood up yelled to me through the falling rain
that the steelhead was a dandy.
Later, Bob Thompson and I went upstream to fish a good pool near the
falls. We waded a good distance before we could cross to the other side.
Fishing this particular pool is best from that side. The crossing was
difficult, and I mentioned to Bob that I would keep an eye on the rising
water level because the walk back to the truck would be a couple of
miles with a steep uphill climb to Route 5 if we were unable to re-cross
the creek. Twenty minutes later with the on going late evening downpour,
the creek level marker I was observing disappeared. I shouted to Bob
that we need to go as the water level was becoming
a serious issue. We attempted to cross the creek at the same spot we
crossed earlier, but the rush of water over the shale bottom would have
swept our feet out from under us if we ventured much further out into
the creek. We decided to pick our way downstream on the left bank. About
a hundred or so yards downstream I knew of a possible crossing that
did not have the usual V bottom slate washout. Carefully we angled out
into the water and with the aid of our wading staffs, slowly made our
way across the roaring tabletop rush of water. Bob and I have been caught
up in several dubious wading situations in the past and we pride ourselves
on our ability to adjust promptly and calmly to unexpected potentially
volatile situations. Remember, safety is paramount when on the water
so do not over reach your wading self confidence.
Later that evening we watched the Weather
Channel and saw the radar images of the storm event that had stalled
over the area from Cleveland through Buffalo. Erie was about centered
in the stalled storm and projections were for one to two more days of
rain because of lack of winds to move the storm out of our fishing area.
The consensus of the group was to go home since the creeks were unfishable,
and to formulate plans for a return steelhead fishing trip in November.
On the way home, I kept thinking about the excellent steelhead fishing
that would be present when the tributaries returned to fishable levels.
The steelhead would be higher in the tributaries and the anglers would
have more fishable waters, thus lessening the fishing pressure. A win-win
situation for the steelhead fishers. I have to add that in spite of
the streams being in a nearly unfishable condition, our group still
caught fish and large ones at that. Upon returning home, I was lamenting
to Gayle just how good that trip should have been and she reminded me
that, unfortunately, the weather is not something we can control. I
guess we all need to remember this and realize, that no matter how carefully
we plan, Mother Nature has the last say!
***UPDATE
FOR 8/17/10***
I was asked by CVTU Program Coordinator,
Tom Baltz, to put together a program for the monthly Membership meeting
of our TU Chapter. The meeting
month for the program was July, so naturally the program subject would
be Tricorythodes or as commonly referred to as Tricos. I would prepare
a Power Point program as an electronic "show and tell" and
Ken Okorn, who has training in the field of aquatic biology, would assist
in the program section regarding Trico hatch habits. Clark Hall and
Jerry Kerstetter, both talented fly tiers, would then demonstrate the
tying of Trico fly patterns that have proven effective for them, not
only on the Yellow Breeches, but also on other waters that feature a
good Trico hatch. I was excited about the upcoming Membership meeting
and felt we were putting together a very interesting and informative
program. Then two days before the event, my PC crashed along with my
Power Point program! I thought the recently completed Trico Power Point
program to be one of the better programs that I had assembled. Combined
with the loss of other documents and pictures, the PC crash was akin
to a shipwreck. The program went on as scheduled without the Trico Power
Point. Ken and I presented the narrative portion and Clark and Jerry
did the fly tying portion. Following are the highlights from the narrative
portion of that program.
Trico on the Yellow Breeches appear
in good numbers from late June through early November when the first
heavy frost of the fall occurs. Tricos have appeared as early as May
on the Yellow Breeches but trout do not seem interested in them at that
time. The best fishing is usually from mid July to early September.
That time frame may vary according to weather conditions. For example
the blowtorch type weather that was experienced in the
Cumberland Valley this summer has reduced the number of Tricos in
August. The Yellow Breeches water temperatures have gone up a degree
or two and might have contributed to the recent decline in Trico numbers.
Tricos need cool streams and good but not great water quality to flourish.
They seem to do best in cool, fertile streams with a slightly silty
substrate. What other mayfly hatch offers 120 plus days of consistent
dry fly fishing opportunity!
One of my points at the CVTU Members
Meeting emphasized the advantage of being the first fly fisher on the
water in the morning. If that was not possible, then definitely, be
the second. Trico fishing is a morning event. In June and July, first
light to mid morning are the action hours. Arrive well after first light
and the best fishing spots are usually occupied, so get there early.
Watching others catch trout after trout in the best feeding lanes is
not a pleasant way to spend the morning. As the Trico season progresses
into late July and early August, the trout become more active about
7:00 a.m. Remember first light gradually occurs later, hour wise, as
late summer and fall approach.
The question is often asked if the size of Tricos vary during the summer?
The naturals may not vary in size but the fly you present needs to do
just that. Early on in late June and early July, a size 22 and size
24 hand tied Trico fly will be accepted by the trout. Why? Because trout
are focused on the naturals and feed voraciously. Your oversized fly
is readily accepted because the fishing pressure has not been overwhelming.
Also, the slightly larger version of the natural bug is easier to see
and this results in the fly fisher's increased confidence, thus more
fish are caught and released. As the trout are caught and released (a
good practice where ever you fish) and the fishing pressure mounts,
they become aware of size, along with presentation and fly tying quality.
Hopefully by now, the fly fisher
has the confidence to downsize the fly, otherwise it is going to be
a limited or fishless morning. Mid August is the time for the size 26
fly that better resembles the natural's size. However, presentation
remains paramount. I remember the first trip Gayle and I took to Montana
(September, 2003) and while fishing the Big Horn one early morning,
we discovered a carpet of Tricos in the area we were fishing. Retrieving
a few naturals from the water's surface, we realized that our Trico
flies that we used back East were too small. The naturals were a size
20 and in some cases, a size 18. That evening at Fort
Smith, MT we tied flies to match the naturals and were on the water
the following morning at first light. Our success that morning reflected
paying attention to the size of the naturals on the Big Horn and tying
the appropriate size flies.
Why do Tricos provide 120 plus
days of mayfly fishing? Are Tricos multi brooded? Ken Okorn covered
these items in his part of the program to the CVTU Members. He cited
the following. There is contradictory information from various sources
on the specifics of the life cycle of Tricos. We compared that information
with our own observations and the observations of other fly fishers
and biologists. The staff of the Little
Lehigh fly shop is particularly knowledgable, having done detailed
observations on their Tricos. Some references state that Tricos are
multi-brooded. This term is generally used to describe those insects
that produce more than one generation in a 12 month period, such as
some species of Baetis and Isonychia. We were unable to document that
this occurs with Tricos. Those other species generally have a distinct
interval between broods, while the Trico emerges continuously for three
to four months. We must keep in perspective that none of this matters
when it comes to actually catching trout.
There is general agreement on
the basic life cycle of Tricos. Male Trico duns emerge overnight and
do not provide much of an opportunity for fly fishers. They probably
molt into spinners in streamside vegetation. Females emerge at, or shortly
after, first light and fly to streamside vegetation to molt into spinners.
Male spinners form swarms over the water, or sometimes over land near
the stream bank, often in sheltered areas. They are then joined by the
females. After mating, the male spinners fall spent on the water. It
is believed that the females briefly return to the streamside vegetation
to provide an opportunity for the fertilized eggs to "ripen".
The females then return to the stream to deposit their greenish egg
masses. After egglaying, the female spinners fall spent. All of this
takes place relatively early in the day. Tricos are small, dark bodied,
and spend a lot of time in the air. This combination would result in
dehydration if the cycle extended into the heat of the day.
The daily Trico cycle can be broken
down into four major fishable events:
1. Emergence of the female duns in the early morning. They have olive
or green abdomens at this time. The emergence generally occurs later
in the morning as the summer progresses.
2. The male spinners form a swarm, and, they are soon joined by the
females. After mating, the male spinners drop to the water, and the
females briefly return to streamside vegetation. The male spinner fall
is often the major fishable event of the day.
3. The females return from streamside vegetation, lay eggs, then fall
spent. Once the egglaying is complete, the abdomen is white in color.
4. The spinners float for a while then eventually sink. Once the fish
have stopped rising, good fishing is often still available by fishing
a subsurface Trico pattern. Charlie Meck has written extensively about
this often overlooked opportunity.
It is important to note that the
above fishable events often overlap. One of the challenges of fishing
Tricos is determining which stage the fish are feeding on at the time.
There is also contradictory information on how Tricos emerge. Some references
state that they emerge in the manner of most mayflies, struggling from
the shuck on the surface. Others say that they become duns under water,
coming to the surface as fully formed duns like the Quill Gordon. We
have not observed shucks on the water during a Trico emergence, nor
have we seen Trico duns stuck in the shuck. However, Thomas Ames, Jr,
in "A Hatch Guide
for New England Streams", states that Tricos emerge both on
and below the surface. We have tried various Trico emerger patterns
on our local streams, including the CDC emerger suggested in the Ames,
Jr. book, without much success.
In summary, the nymph and the
male dun are not important to fly fishers. Fishing an emerger pattern
during the female dun emergence is said to be effective, although we
have not found this to be the case. The female dun, the male and female
spinner, and the drowned spinners are the most important stages for
fly fishers to match.
1. Be the first on the water, if you can't be the first fly fisher on
the water, be the second!
2. Don't step on the biggest fish of the morning by rushing into the
water. Good feed lanes are found near the stream banks and big fish
target those areas so don't be in a rush to reach mid stream.
3. Match the naturals with the proper sized fly. Use hooks in sizes
26-24 with wide gaps. The wide gap enhances hook ups. Use the 24 size
hook in the early part of the Trico season and then use the size 26
hook in mid summer and early fall.
4. Avoid micro drag by using shorter casts and hackled duns.
5. Target a single feeding fish and time the arrival of the fly as the
fish resurfaces to sip a natural. Do not toss the fly into the feeding
pod of fish and hope for a hookup.
6. At times, the double Trico hackled or spent wing fly pattern on a
single hook works. If the hatch is heavy, trout will make the most of
a surface effort by gulping two or more naturals.
7. Keep the fly floating by applying a generous amount of fumed silica
better known as Frog's Fanny. A high floating fly also helps with visibility
and results in increased hookups.
8. Use 7X or 8X fluorocarbon tippet material. 6X fluorocarbon will suffice
in rippely water.
9. Trim the bottom hackles on hackled duns. Flush floating flies seem
to be more effective.
10. 2, 3, and 4 weight rods in 8 to 8.5 foot lengths and medium action
do a nice job when fishing the Trico hatches. The important thing is
to use a rod that allows the user to present the fly as drag free as
possible.
11. Cast downstream to feeding fish using a recoil, slack or other method
that allows the fly line to land on the surface in a serpentine pattern.
These types of casts eliminate micro drag and fish respond to the fly
first approach.
12. Tapered leaders and tippet materials absorb water so treat occasionally
with liquid floatant.
13. Unsure if a stream has Tricos, check nearby spider webs. Nature
provides a batteryless natural gismo that is fool proof.
14. Do not leave the water after the surface activity stops. Rig a tandem
of spent spinner male spinners and fish them as drowned Tricos. Another
excellent tandem rig is a bead head green weenie with a spent spinner
dropped off the bend of the hook. The nymph fly fishers should excel
at this method.
***UPDATE
FOR 7/6/10***
The rain was tolerable but the
No-See-Ums
were not! The minute critters with what seemed like auger jaws bored
in the side of my neck, along the outline of my beard and under my sleeve
cuffs. I said a few bad words, well, maybe more than a few, but was
determined that this brand of torture would not deter me from some of
the finest wild brown trout fishing on the east coast. The first of
several wild brown trout caught under these trying conditions made the
agony worthwhile!
On June 9, 2010, five members
of the Cumberland Valley Trout
Unlimited (CVTU) Chapter returned to Penns Creek for several days
of fishing. Our first trip to Penns Creek was noted in the 5/5/20 Recent
News and Happenings update. Our lodging was the well-located and comfortable
Camp Guttaluta (named after the famed Green Drake hatch on Penns Creek)
owned by CVTU member Mark Campbell. It is located on the lower end of
the Catch and Release project water near Cherry Run. Mark can be reached
at cbimark@aol.com or 717.880.1604. We were not sure what the water
level, stream temperature and hatches would offer up. Rain was the order
of the day upon arrival and after unloading all the gear and food supplies
we hit the stream. It was slightly after 3:30 PM and a size 18 Olive
blanketed the waters. However, fish were up but not taking the olive
duns. Close observation revealed that when a larger bug popped to the
surface and caused any motion, the result was an instant take of that
bug. I collected several bugs and then rummaged through my fly boxes
for something that might duplicate the critter. The bug appeared to
be a large Olive but later that evening we consulted an Entomology book
and a book of hatches and keyed the critter. Interesting that after
the natural matured several hours, the overall colors changed and the
bug did resemble the Isonychia pictured in the Entomology book. Slate
Drake, Leadwing Coachman, Dun Variant and Mahogany Dun are some of the
common names applied to this bug. Indeed it was an Isonychia. The initial
olive sheen and light wing color of the freshly emerged dun mislead
me to believe it was an Olive that no one else has seen on Penns Creek.
I was about ready to send the specimen to Greg Hoover, noted Entomologist
at Penn State University, when Ken Okorn and Tom Houf burst my Hollywood
bubble and brought my mind and ego back to earth when they both proclaimed
that the fly I had was an Isonychia! Or more commonly known as the Slate
Drake. No big discovery here. Another trait that threw me off on the
identification of the Isonychia was past readings reported by many writers
that Isonychia migrate toward the bank and crawl up on logs and sticks
in the shallow water to hatch like stoneflies. Some Isonychia nymphs
find the downstream side of large rocks favorable and crawl up to hatch.
Further reading on my part uncovered that when the weather in June is
unsettled and rain and cooler temperature set in, like this trip, the
naturals will be forced to emerge on the surface. See why I was mislead?
Fishing to the Isonychia or Slate
Drake was happenstance until one evening when I walked upstream to fish
a long glide below the Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission cabin.
A gentleman from the Sunbury area was at the upper end of the glide
and catching fish off the surface with a caddis emerger. Since I only
had waist high waders and the glide was deep I asked him if he was fishing
further into the glide and he replied no. The fish were rising too steadily
for him to move. I moved downstream and entered the water at what turned
out to be just the right depth for the waist waders. I checked my watch
and it was 7:30 PM. Several fish began to rise in the foam line a good
distance away. I tied on a caddis emerger and made numerous long distance
casts but without success. I rummaged through my fly box and noted one
fly that had been successful in the Adirondacks when the Isonychia were
present. It was a personalized copy of the Money Fly made famous by
the late Fran Betters of that area. Personalized means that the hackle
that Fran used was omitted and the body dubbing was beaver dark tan
dubbing, not the dark gray muskrat fur Fran normally used. This was
a basic fly (my type of tying) with only calf hair protruding out over
the eye of the hook and the beaver dark tan dubbing.
After several hookups and releases,
the fisher above me asked what the H**L I was using. My reply was the
Money Fly. Unfortunately I only had one Money Fly and related that to
him. I felt badly that I could not have given Rod (I always try to get
the names of the fishers I talk with when on stream) a Money Fly. However,
I informed Rod that the personalized Money Fly would be a Fly of the
Week on my website in the near future. So here it is Rod. Check out
the Fly of the Week for general tying instructions for the Money Fly
and perhaps next June we will meet up again on Penns Creek and catch
some of the wild browns that bring fishers, like us, back year after
year. Below is the meaningful email I received from Rod.
Greetings Gene,
I am the guy you schooled in
the hole below the Conservation Cabin on Penns Creek last night. I enjoyed
our conversation and took your advice about checking out your web site.
Your Fly of the Week is a great resource. I found a few patterns that
I am going to tie and test. I'll let you know how I do. Perhaps the
next fly of the week will be the Money Fly.
Tight lines and best wishes
for a great summer season.
Rod
Sunbury, PA
***UPDATE
FOR 6/12/10***
It was big water with a background
of big mountains and, framed between the water and mountains, was a
big bird. It was a Bald Eagle being hurried upstream by an attacking
crow. Usually it is the crow that harasses the discovered owl but this
was the first time I witnessed a crow harassing an eagle. The eagle
appeared only slightly agitated as the pair flew by about 100 feet above
water level. I yelled to Clark who was 200 feet below me on Pine Creek
and we both watched the airborne pair continue their flight upstream
toward Slate Run and the entrance to the Grand Canyon of Pennsylvania.
My attention returned to fishing
because several good-sized fish were working the surface within casting
distance of my four-weight fly rod. Clark had several fish working the
surface near him and soon he was fast to one of those big fish. That
fish turned out to be one of the large German Brown trout that is stocked
in the stream. This is made possible by sponsor money and purchases
of trout stocking Gold Member pins by anglers, the majority of which
is fly fishers. These were available from Wolf's
General Store and Orvis Fly Shop at Slate Run. Owner Tom Finkbiner
has had the program in place for several years and the response from
the fishing public has been positive. The Delayed Harvest Artificial
Lures Only Section of Pine Creek at Slate Run was reminiscent of a western
stream and has generated a western type fishing atmosphere with the
combination of big fish, big water and big mountains. Sixteen of the
fish purchased and stocked were in the four to eight pound range and
lengths were 24 inches and longer. Steelhead size fish on Pine Creek?
You bet! The majority of the fish bought and stocked were in the 16
to 19 inch range.
June 1, 2010 marked the third
year that Gayle and I returned to the Slate Run area of the Pine Creek
Valley with six or more couples from the Cumberland
Valley Trout Unlimited Chapter. On this trip we had eight couples
plus six guys for a total of twenty-two and we believe all had an enjoyable
time. Pine Creek is one of several Chapter fishing trips and has not
disappointed us with the lodging, hatches, fishing and, most importantly,
the water level and weather conditions. An added bonus, during the past
years, we were entertained with different black bear sightings. During
our stay we did not see as many bear as in the past but as will be noted
on the next update home page photos, we saw a huge bear and two little
guys or girls that we fondly referred to as little back bowling balls
with ears.
Memorial Day was a week later
this year and the hatches were a week or so earlier so the bugs were
different than past years. For example, past years we could expect hatches
of March Browns and Gray Foxes, Olives, Green and Brown Drakes and the
failsafe Caddis bugs. This trip however, hatches of a size 22 little
Blue Winged Olive in the morning and again at noon, supplemented with
a size 16 Blue Winged Olive in the afternoon were the mainstay hatches.
Random appearances of the Slate Drake, the Sulphur and the light Cahill
rounded out the other offerings. A smattering of Gray Fox were also
noted. The USGS gage at Cedar Run was reading 1.94 feet upon arrival,
which is low by Pine Creek standards and continued to drop as the trip
unfolded. Water temperatures in the Slate Run area ranged from a mid
day high of 73 degrees F. to a morning low of 66 degrees F. Successful
anglers from our group reported taking trout off the surface with the
two sizes of Olives, the Slate Drake in parachute style, CDC Sulphur
Cripple/Emergers, tied V Midge style (see CVTU's Favorite Flies book,
page 52), Porcupine Quill (same book, page 55), and the ubiquitous Flymph.
Those anglers fishing subsurface reported good results with the Gold
Ribbed Hare's Ear, in various sizes, as well as the Pheasant Tail, egg
fly, pink worm and Woolly Bugger. All in all it was a very productive
and enjoyable trip.
NOTE: I have so many good photos
from this trip that I plan to include some of them in the next update.
***UPDATE
FOR 5/5/10***
Planning a multiple
night trip on Penns Creek in April and May can be dicey. During periods
of heavy precipitation, the vast agricultural areas upstream can send
a heavy flow of silt laden water into Penns Creek and can also raise
the water level in a short period of time. Plowed farm fields with limited
or no crop cover exposes the soil to serious erosion. This is certainly
not scientific, but it is based on my many years of fishing Penns Creek
in the Poe Paddy, Coburn and Weikert areas. However, when one hits the
perfect conditions, which consist of USGS gage levels between 2.10 and
2.45 feet and no heavy precipitation forecast in the near future, then
go fish Penns Creek.
A group of us did
so the middle part of April and experienced a dream trip. We fished
the stretch from Cherry Run up to Swift Run on the Catch and Release
section. This stretch consisted of approximately 3.9 miles of remote
territory and if we experienced overcrowding on the stream it was our
own fault for not moving along. The tail end of a respectable hatch
of Grannom Caddis, coupled with a light sprinkling of March Browns and
Hendricksons made the trip a surface fly fishers paradise. See Fly of
the Week offerings # 16, # 42 and # 17 for successful patterns that
I used on this trip. Tan Caddis appeared a few days into the trip and
the fish seemed to favor the little critters, at times by passing the
heartier naturals like the size 14-12 Grannoms, the size 12-10 March
Browns and the size 14 Hendricksons. Those of us that indulged the fish
subsurface, when the surface activity was not favorable, did well on
nymphs and emergers like the Illegal Nymph and Flash Caddis Emerger.
See Fly of the Week # 52 and # 49 respectively.
The trip began to
unfold at the Cumberland Valley TU Chapter Limestoner Banquet in late
March when Mark Campbell, owner of Camp Guttulata on Penns Creek donated
a four nights stay package. The bid process followed and several of
us had a successful bid that generated nearly $700 to our TU Chapter
coffers for cold water conservation measures. BIG thanks to Mark Campbell!
Mark's cabin is located in a prime spot within walking distance of Penns
Creek and many of our group did not have to venture far to experience
western type fishing in Pennsylvania. Accommodations are first rate
and six to eight persons can utilize the facility in comfort. Our group
consisted of several cooks and each one prepared their specialty for
dinner. Camp Guttulata has the equipped kitchen area to accommodate
the beginner to the specialty cook. A day of fishing on Penns Creek
can burn a few calories and at day's end, returning to a gourmet type
meal is a winning experience! Mark Campbell can be reached at 717-880-1604
or CBIMark@aol.com should you be
interested in contacting him for excellent accommodations on Penns Creek.
The photos on the
home page attest to the wonders and enjoyment of fishing Penns Creek
and having distinctive accommodations like Mark Campbell's Camp Guttulata
to enhance the fishing trip. Incidentally, the name Camp Guttulata is
based on the spectacular Green Drake (Ephemera guttulata) hatch on Penns
Creek.
***UPDATE
FOR 4/20/10***
The latter part of March and the
early part of April provide plentiful opportunities to catch fish on
wet flies. Here in the Cumberland Valley and later in the streams up
north the early season hatches that are comprised of Grannom Caddis,
Blue Winged Olives, Quill Gordons, Red Quill, and Hendricksons bring
out the fly fishers in good numbers. Combine the timeliness of the key
hatches with closed approved trout waters, and project waters like Delayed
Harvest Artificial Lures Only (DHALO), Catch and Release Fly-Fishing
Only, and Catch and Release (for example, the section on Yellow Breeches
from Boiling Springs to the vicinity of Allenberry)
become crowded. There are many advantages to the early opening of trout
season in PA's Southeastern sector and one of them is spreading out
the spring fly fishers and allowing the pressured project waters to
return to some sense of normalcy. The period from March 1, to the opening
day, April 3, this year did compress what seemed to be a larger number
of fly fishers into the limited project waters open for fishing. I believe
that periods of unseasonable high temperatures during that time frame
provided the incentive for anglers to get out on the water and resulted
in the unusual number of anglers on project waters.
Recently on the Catch and Release
section of the Yellow Breeches the evening surface activity was a mystery.
Mike Goyne was fishing below me and had gone through several subsurface
flies and then switched over to surface flies. He yelled up to me asking
what the trout were taking off the surface. I had a good view of the
bugs that were flitting above the rippled water and answered that it
was a combination of female Hendricksons with their lemon colored egg
sacs, Craneflies and numerous Tan Caddis. However, I was not exactly
sure which of the bugs or a combination of the bugs the fish were taking.
I started the process of elimination by tying on a Hendrickson. I don't
tie female Hendrickson with egg sacs because they usually jettison the
eggs sacs above the water. I tried the dead drift and skittering methods
but had no luck. Next I tied on the Tan Caddis and tried the dead drift
and skittering methods with the same results I had using the Hendrickson.
I then tied on the Cranefly and finally caught two trout. The Cranefly
may seem ungainly and not as favorable as the sleek Mayflies to the
fly fishers but it does produce results. As I further watched the bug
activity in the waning light, I noted trout attempting to catch the
bugs in mid air that were mere inches off the surface. This type of
action has frustrated me for years. When the Black Caddis dance above
the water's surface in the summer months and fish attempt to catch them
by leaping out of the water they prove impossible to catch. This activity
is fun to watch, but exasperating when trying to catch trout that are
taking air borne bugs.
My conclusion was to tie a few
more Craneflies for my fly box, which I did. But the more I thought
about the bug activity that evening, the more I realized that a wet
fly and not a dry fly may have been more productive. Could the Hendrickson
and Caddis naturals be in the act of depositing eggs under the surface
and the trout were feeding on the adults while subsurface? The showy
above surface splashes tended to hold my attention and I missed out
on what was really the important sequence of events. That is probably
why I only caught two trout that evening! I have read where Caddis will
swim underwater to deposit eggs but I am not sure if I ever read that
the Hendrickson does the same. Regardless, the next evening I was back
in the riffle and it was a repeat of the bug activity the previous evening.
This time I tied on wet flies that have been kind to me in the past
and, by swinging the slightly weighted tandem rig down and across, the
fish responded. The point fly was a size 14 Illegal Nymph mayfly wet
fly and the dropper was a size 16 Grannom Caddis wet fly. My lesson
learned was that sometimes the obviously active bug is not necessarily
the bug that the fish are taking. Therefore, don't get so caught up
in the obvious that you overlook what is really happening. For more
information on the wet flies mentioned above, see the Fly
of the Week link.
***UPDATE
FOR 3/30/10***
My first 2010 steelhead
trip to Erie took place in mid March from a Tuesday through Friday time
frame. The lower sections of the Mile creeks on the East side of Erie
were occupied with more than sufficient anglers so I decided to walk
upstream in the hope of finding steelhead occupied water without many
anglers present. I selected 20 Mile Creek because I hold both a PA and
a NY fishing licenses. The walk entailed several miles through some
rugged areas with cliffs that towered approximately 60 yards high in
some places. Fortunately when the creek meandered close to the base
of the towering cliff on one side, the other side cliff was situated
far enough away from the creek to allow me to cross over and continue
my fishing journey upstream. I snapped forty or more digital photos
and could have taken many more as the wind and water erosion processes
over the eons of time have sculpted some impressive sights. For example,
mature trees on the precipice held upright by what appeared to be just
a few roots was astonishing. The creek side root system was fully exposed
and the tree appeared to be hanging in mid air. Looking up and through
the network of exposed roots makes one fully aware that at any time
the tree could come plummeting down. One pool had a clump of birch trees
that had done just that down the 60 yards or so cliff face and, at the
bottom on the creek's edge, had landed upright with sufficient shale
and dirt to continue growing. I wondered if the next high water event
would sweep the oasis away. That pool held some steelhead trout and
the Titan Minnow accounted for two hookups. However, I began to realize
that when a new pool or likely holding spot was approached, I usually
caught one steelhead. Repetitive casts with the Titan Minnow or replacement
fly yielded no further hookups. So my approach upstream was to fish
a likely holding area, catch a steelhead, make several more casts just
in case and then move on. This approach allowed the covering of a lot
of water.
Interesting that
all of the steelhead caught were nicked in some way from what I perceived
to be ice out damage. Looking at the huge cakes of glacial like ice
that remained along the creek's edges one could see how a fish could
be in harm's way when the ice up broke free due to warming temperatures
and high water. I did not encounter any fresh fish that would indicate
that the spring run was on. Furthermore, the spring run activity seems
to be more concentrated from Route 20 and Route 5 bridges to the lake.
Lake Erie did provide some fine sunset photo shooting opportunities.
It was remarkable how fast the lake ice split and moved over the several
days I was in the area. An area that appeared solid with ice would suddenly
become blue depending on the direction the wind was blowing and the
wind intensity.
March is a good time
to fish steelhead in the Erie area. Past years' steelhead trout fishing
experience has the month of November ranked at the top and the month
of March ranked second. March 2009 was a good month for steelhead fishing
and hopefully March 2010 will not be a disappointment so make your plans
to fish steelhead trout soon.
***UPDATE FOR 3/2/10***
On February 16,
the Pennsylvania Fish
and Boat Commission stock truck arrived at the designated meeting
location in Boiling Springs. WCO David Hurst formulated the plans
for the float stocking of the Run, a connector from Children's Lake
to the main stem of the Yellow Breeches, and the upper Catch and
Release section on the Yellow Breeches. Cumberland
Valley TU Chapter (CVTU) members were on hand to float stock
the approximately 700 robust trout allocated to the day's stocking
effort. The effort by Cumberland Valley TU Chapter (CVTU) members
to float stock trout has resulted in improved distribution of trout
and angler satisfaction. If an area on the stream looked like it
should hold fish it did! Those CVTU members knew where to place
the trout for optimum food and cover and released trout accordingly.
Special thanks to Jim Siedlarczyk, CVTU member, who shoveled a path
of well over fifty yards from the Run to the main stem of the Yellow
Breeches for those volunteers that were carrying buckets of fish.
We seniors especially appreciated his work by not having to post
hole through two feet of snow to stock the trout.
Just a reminder
that we will soon be in the time frame when many streams, lakes,
ponds and reservoirs in the Commonwealth will be closed to all fishing
from March 1 to 8:00 a.m. on the opening day of the trout season.
Pennsylvania has two trout openers, April 3 and April 17.
However, there
are Special Project Waters that are open to fishing year round (no
closed seasons) If in doubt about fishing a particular water area,
consult your nearest Fish and Boat Commission office. Information
for those offices is provided on page 40 of the 2010
Pennsylvania Fishing Summary booklet.
***UPDATE
FOR 2/10/10***
My boss, in my
working life, was very active in the outdoors and he was fond of
saying that there was no such thing as bad weather only bad gear.
He was right as usual because, with the advancement in breathable
inner and outer wear including waders, there is no compelling reason
to stay indoors during inclement weather unless you are unable to
afford the sometimes high prices for good gear or cannot enjoy winter
fishing due to health reasons. Read on and make the necessary purchases/adjustments
and enjoy winter fly fishing.
I fish four seasons
of the year and am often asked how I fare in the coldest winter
months. My response is "quite well" and honestly, when
fishing to the early morning Trico hatch in August when the weather
is hot and humid I prefer the winter fishing. A high number of January
winter days in the Cumberland Valley boast an average temperature
of 37-38 degrees F. and coupled with sunshine and early afternoon
midge activity and occasional Little Blue Winged Olive activity
make for an exciting fly fishing experience. Besides, I have yet
to experience crowded stream conditions in the winter! Sunshine
on my shoulders in the winter is most enjoyable. Add that to fly
fishing to trout sipping midges and LBWO and you have a perfect
fly fishing experience.
This is how I
dress for a winter day's fly fishing. Close to my body I like good
quality hydrophobic briefs and undershirts that do not absorb moisture.
Next a base layer of heavyweight wading underwear of polyester stretch
fleece. Both of the above mentioned under garments provide excellent
layering and wick off perspiration in cold water conditions (the
secret to winter fishing comfort). Add a layer of heavyweight fleece,
200 or more weight. wading pants and equal fleece weight pull over
shirt. Like the briefs and long underwear, both items assist in
wicking away moisture from the skin. The walk-in to the stream may
consist of a short distance or in the case of remote streams like
Penns Creek, a half mile or more walk may be required. I then layer
with a breathable quick drying fleece jacket. Often I fish in deep
water so my final outer layer is a hooded angling jacket for waterproof
protection. The important /vital part is the waterproof sleeves
because one can only hold arms up so long when casting and fishing.
Eventually the arms become fatigued and the elbows sag into the
water and it is at that time a waterproof wading jacket is of value.
Now that the body is well ventilated and insulated what about the
head and hands? Windstopper type fleece gloves, with or without
full finger coverage, is great for comfort and the resulting warmth
fleece provides. A ball cap under a hooded wading jacket is sufficient
especially if one relies on a flip down magnifying glass for ease
of tying on tippet material or flies. However, for those that have
sharp eyes, a fleece watch cap type of hat that is comfortable and
warm is hard to beat. Now for the waders. I prefer breathable boot-foot
waders, but they can be hard to find. Evidently the technology of
securing the boot to the uppers has not been perfected and leakage
is a possibility around the seams. Also, most breathable boot-foot
waders contain less than the desired amount of insulation. The average
insulation consists of about 200 grams of Thinsulate, which may
be adequate for non-winter fishing trips. Neoprene waders are rugged
and, with 600 grams or more of Thinsulate in the boot, is a good
choice but the waders can be a bit bulky for us senior citizens.
However, neoprene waders do not have the important breathable feature
and moisture tends to build up, resulting in eventual cool, then
cold clammy feeling that can mitigate time on the stream.
All of that information,
if utilized, will make for a comfortable day of fly fishing regardless
of the weather. Saturday, following weekend of the heavy snow, found
two feet + of the white fluffy stuff in my backyard. I made my way
out to the stream with the aide of snowshoes, which I removed at
stream edge, and was able to enjoy several hours of top notch fly
fishing. Even released two nice brown trout for my effort. Don't
give in to cabin fever and the winter doldrums. Don the appropriate
winter wear and go out to you favorite stream for a fantastic day
of fishing. That puts Punxsutawney
Phil in the proper prospective
.six more weeks of winter
who
cares?!
***UPDATE
FOR 1/25/10***
The 2010 fishing
season is starting to crank up with improvements in the weather
and trout stocking in the Yellow Breeches Creek. The weather has
been brutal the past two weeks with daytime highs well below normal
and nighttime lows also several degrees below normal for this time
of year, combined with 40 mile per hour winds. This is not a good
recipe for wading into a stream and it is down right unappealing.
This is farm show week and weather is traditionally ugly in the
Harrisburg, PA area. However, the weatherman is predicting an upturn
and daytime temperatures may hit the 40 degrees F. mark, something
we have not seen in the past two weeks. Anglers are looking forward
with anticipation to a weather pattern that will bring the Yellow
Breeches watershed area to above freezing. We may finally reach
normal day and night time temperatures before the farm show grand
finale! Could this reprieve be the January thaw?
Now, to the fishing
segment. I started the New Year off with my traditional day of fishing
and did not catch a fish. I worked the surface with midge patterns
that have proven effective during winter weather conditions and
not one lean and hungry fish looking for a Happy Meal (pardon the
commercial fast food endorsement) opted for my offerings. Oh well,
Penn State was about to play in the Capital One Bowl against LSU
so thumbs down to the fish as I headed for the warmth and wide screen
of a football day during Bowl Season. However, those of us fortunate
enough to live in the Cumberland Valley, and those anglers that
live within a two hour driving window of the famed Yellow Breeches,
have known for years about the highly anticipated, highly participated
first weekend in January when the Yellow Breeches Anglers and Conservation
Association stock trout, weather permitting. The Yellow
Breeches Anglers and Conservation Association, Inc. performs
its annual winter stocking of trout along an approximately 13-mile
stretch of the Yellow Breeches. Traditionally, Childrens Lake,
the Run, and the Yellow Breeches Catch and Release areas are stocked
the day prior to float stocking other reaches of the creek. There
just arent enough day light hours to complete the job in one
day. This is the ultimate win-win situation for anglers and the
best way to take the edge off of winters predictable cabin
fever. Somehow, seeing the flashing amber light atop the green truck
with the yellow aeration tanks and large YBAC stenciling moving
through the Boiling Springs area, summons the urge to go fishing
and provides fresh insight that winter should not mean the disappearance
of the angling spirit. The YBAC is a significant driving force displaying
a spirit of determination to maximize fishing opportunities for
all anglers residing in and outside the Cumberland Valley. Its
members volunteer for extra work and demanding assignments that
go beyond what is expected to operate a Nursery that annually raises
and stocks over 36,000 trout. A 2010 membership, at a cost of $12
adult and $3 Junior (under 16), maximizes the four season fishing
opportunity for all anglers!!
On Friday, January
15, the cooperative weather finally allowed the stocking of trout
in Childrens Lake, the Run and the main stem of the Yellow
Breeches Catch and Release section. On Saturday, January 16, the
open water above and below the catch and release area was stocked.
Some nice fish in the 15 to 20 inch range were strategically placed
where those anglers that ventured from the cozy confines of the
parking areas would be pleasantly rewarded.
Interesting,
after the trout stocking, a few of us did some kick sampling of
the Yellow Breeches bottom utilizing a D Ring net and were
astounded at the number and variety of bugs collected. The bugs
consisted of an inch and quarter size stonefly, Hendrickson nymphs,
Sulphur nymphs, Blue Winged Olive nymphs, one Trico nymph, Scuds,
and an impressive number of free-living caddis larvae. Ken Okorn
took an interest in the free-living worm like caddis critters that
really cant swim but can move about by use of the front legs.
These caddis larvae are found in and under riffle rocks where they
move about searching for the food that the fast moving water pushes
by. Ken noted that he was going to tie up a few of the worm like
critters and fish them the next day. We then moved about 40 yards
downstream, into quieter water, and retrieved a short piece of waterlogged
tree branch. There we found numerous cased Grannom caddis attached.
The rich combination of Hendrickson nymphs and cased Grannom caddis
will provide some interesting and exciting roll over hatch activity
in late March and early April.
Well, Ken made
good on his promise to tie up a few free-living worm like caddis
and was on the creek the following morning along with fishing buddy,
Jim Ritter. Now, Ken had surgery on his right thumb and wrist in
December and just recently had the cast removed. He is working on
regaining the dexterity he once had so Kens fishing consisted
of utilizing the Czech Nymph style of fishing by extending the fly
rod with one hand and literally fishing a short line under the rod
tip. The reason Ken was Czech nymphing was because he was not allowed
(doctors orders) to use his right hand. The orders were to
not lift more than eight ounces and not to push or pull anything.
So he improvised by holding the rod in the left hand and tightening
the drag all the way down. Thus he did not have to cast, which would
have required reeling with the healing right hand. The positive
was that Ken was out fishing but the negative was the occasional
loss of a hefty trout because he could not allow the fish to run
with the set drag. The normal Czech nymphing technique and flies
used are expertly covered in the book entitled Czech Nymph by Karel
Krivanec and Friends. Jim Ritter summed up the morning of fishing
by saying that Ken out fished him with only one hand! See fly of
the week for Kens version of the free-living worm like caddis
critter.
***UPDATE FOR 12/16/09***
Early Wednesday
morning of my five day hunting and fishing trip, the 30 to 40 mile
per hour winds awoke me from a deep sleep at Camp Shanty which is
located on a ridge in NY about eight miles from 20 Mile Creek. My
plan was to hunt that morning for deer and then break camp and drive
the 278 miles home to Boiling Springs, PA. Hunting time was limited,
as I needed to be at a Cumberland Valley Trout Unlimited Board meeting
at 7:00 p.m. I turned on the battery-powered radio and learned that
the winds would continue for the next twelve plus hours, with gusts
reaching 65 mph. More importantly, a lake effect storm was approaching
the area and I know from past experience that can mean sudden snow
fall that is measured in, not inches, but feet. I decided against
the hunting and soon after first light, headed for 16 Mile Creek
for steelhead fishing. Access to the creek from the parked vehicle
was optimal in the event I needed to leave the area quickly as a
result of the building storm front. I was hopeful that I could fish
for several hours and then leave for home on my terms. This plan
has worked in the past because lake effect storms seem to die out
after reaching inland 20 to 50 miles. I would simply outrun the
approaching weather hazard. Gayle always cringes when I make such
plans.
Sunday through
Tuesday, when not deer hunting in the early morning and late afternoon
hours, I had fly fished several of the east side of Erie tributaries
with moderate success as the water was low and gin clear. The cooler
temperatures seemed to be thinning out the number of fair weather
fishers resulting in more open water to fish. The majority of anglers
were taking steelhead using live Emerald and Golden Shiners. I suspect
the main food item in Lake Erie for steelhead is the shiner minnow
and that may have contributed to the angler's success. I had won
a box of Muddler Minnows tied by well-know fly tier Andrew McNeillie
of New Bloomfield, PA at the 2008 Fly Fisher's Club of Harrisburg
banquet and caught several steelhead using the various sized minnows.
However, I tucked away the thought that when home, I needed to do
some research on flies that patterned the shiner minnow.
16 Mile Creek
was off color and the water level was increasing from the borderline
winter mix of sleet, some hail and some snow but the majority of
precipitation was rain. I had the lower end of the creek to myself.
Great!! I suspected that a fresh run of steelhead had entered the
creek and set about to fish certain portions of 16 Mile Creek that
normally hold resting steelhead. Unlike fishing the low and clear
water of the past few days, the steelhead were not interested in
the Muddler Minnow and a modified Pumpkin Picker, see Fly
of the Week number 37, was well received. The modification consisted
of the addition of florescent chartreuse lead barbell eyes to the
fly. Perhaps the extra color zip was not necessary but the extra
weight probably got the fly lower in the water to where the steelhead
were holding. I lost my supply of standard tied Pumpkin Picker's
earlier in the trip and only had four of the modified versions on
hand. I caught and released four steelhead trout in rapid succession.
The fresh run steelhead were strong fighters and rapid succession
translated into about a total time of 40 minutes to catch and release
those four zestful steelhead. Leaves, twigs, limbs, grapevines and
large tree sections were floating downstream from the results of
the menacing winds. As the morning fishing progressed, I lost several
of the hooked steelhead when the fly line and tapered leader would
tangle with the floating debris while the steelhead zig-zagged the
creek. Soon all of the modified Pumpkin Pickers were gone. Coincidentally,
I did not catch another steelhead and it was now 9:30 a.m. I tried
several other patterns that had been productive in the past but
with out success. Either the steelhead only wanted the modified
Pumpkin Picker or the feeding frenzy was over for the morning. Interestingly
I have found steelhead tend to enter short windows of feeding frenzy
from daybreak (this time varies as fall and winter seasons unfold)
to about 9:30 a.m., again from 11:30 a.m. to about 12:30 p.m. and
around 3:30 p.m. to dusk. Again, this time varies as we progress
into the fall and winter seasons.
Next trip to
the Erie area I will have an adequate supply of hand tied Pumpkin
Pickers in regular and modified versions and a good supply of hand
tied Emerald Shiners. Here is what my research uncovered. CVTU's
Favorite Flies book contains a write-up and tying instructions (page
84) for the Emerald Shiner contributed by well known fly tier, fly
fisher and fishing guide Tom Baltz. Also by coincidence Scott Douglas
another well traveled fly fisher who ties great flies sent me an
email
well, just see the current Fly
of the Week and then read Stream Tippets
to see the results.
I made the CVTU
Board meeting on time even though the 278 mile trip home covered
the gamut of weather conditions but I did outrun the bulk of the
storm.
***UPDATE FOR 12/1/09***
It was early
November and the weather was perfect for steelhead fly fishing.
However, the Lake Erie tributaries around Erie, PA, were experiencing
low and clear water conditions. The steelhead were gathered in the
small pools and hordes of anglers (mostly bait fishers) were hovering
around the pools and yanking out the corralled steelhead. Now remember,
these fishers with the bait do not practice catch and release and
they reminded me of the Great Blue Heron that is found along almost
all of our trout streams. If you watch them you will see them spearing
fish after fish. What is the point you say? The Great Blue Heron
does not practice catch and release but does utilize these fish
for sustenance. The majority of bait fishers in the Great Erie Steelhead
Alley may or may not use the fish they catch and keep. Overall,
watching the glutinous taking of the steelhead from the shallow
pools was disheartening!!
I left and headed back to my camp in nearby NY for the evening archery
deer hunt. Later I received a call from a friend, Thom Livingston,
who was bird hunting in the area west of Erie near the Ohio line,
and he asked if I wanted to meet up and fish Chautauqua Creek in
NY. Thom had a NY fishing license and, since my NY Super Sportsman
hunting license included an annual fishing license, I was legal,
so the plans were made. Thom had fished the Chautauqua Creek previously
and was impressed with the volume of water flow that resembled 20
Mile Creek in PA. Also, he stated we would fish the Catch and Release
section of the Chautauqua Creek. The thought of a Catch and Release
steelhead and salmon section caught my interest. You bet,
I said.
The next morning, about 11:00a.m, we meet near the PA/NY line and
drove the approximately 11 miles to Chautauqua Creek. We parked
in an area near the open water fishing along Chautauqua Creek and
talked to several fishers that were coming off the water for a lunch
break. We found out that enough steelhead trout were present to
keep the attention of the fishers. Interesting that one of those
fishers was the person that initiated the Blood Dot Egg Fly and
Blood Dot Sucker Spawn craze. The last name of this individual was
none-the-less Blood. He created the Blood Dot addition to the flies
while living in the Pittsburgh area. Jeff Blood was generous in
that he gave Thom and me several flies with the dot and we told
him that we would not fish his hand tied flies but would use the
gift flies as patterns for our tying at home. Amazing the quality
fly fishers one meets on trout streams!
We fished the open water of Chautauqua Creek below the Route 5 Bridge
and then decided to drive upstream to the town of Westfield and
fish the Catch and Release section. The C&R section begins at
the bridge (South Gale Street) in Westfield, NY. Then upstream 1.3
miles to the upper dam used by the Village of Westfield for water
intake.
Accesses are limited along the C&R section but the NY DEC has
a large parking lot with access to the C&R section about midway
along the C&R. The trail from the large parking lot is steep
and one should be in good shape to access the creek. At the base
of the steep access the waters are inviting and that is where I
met the young lad that had moved to the area from Oregon. He had
a steelhead trout on when I saw him and after he released the fish
I asked him what he was using. Astonishingly, he was catching steelhead
on a subsurface size 20 elk hair caddis presentation! We talked
and he related that the C&R section was the only section of
steelhead water that he fished. The other tributaries were crowded
and he had experienced some callous behavior from other anglers.
I told him I understood his feelings and expounded on some of my
unfortunate experiences on open water. We parted agreeing that more
C&R sections were needed on PA and NY Lake Erie tributaries.
Ill close this update with a request that you contact the
PA Fish and Boat Commission (www.fish.state.pa.us) and stress the
importance of C&R steelhead sections on Lake Erie tributaries
East and West of Erie. DO IT NOW! Remember, tomorrow may be too
late!
***UPDATE
FOR 11/4/09***
It is encouraging
and refreshing to talk to younger fly fishers that are enthusiastic
about the sport, especially when it comes to steelhead trout fishing.
Such was the case on a recent Saturday when I entered the Yellow
Breeches Outfitters to talk to Gary who was working at the time.
I haven't seen Gary in a week to ten days and I wanted to update
him on a recent archery hunting and steelhead fishing trip that
Gayle and I enjoyed. I told Gary about the harsh weather we encountered
on our way across Interstate 80 between the State College, Clearfield
and Dubois areas. The snow was impressive and the driving required
full attention on the road conditions. Needless to say, many drivers
of vehicles passed us with one arm pasted to their ear engaged in
cell phone conversations.
Anyway back to
the fishing. A young lad by the name of Jason Bubb, from the Dover,
Pa, area overheard our conversation and began to ask questions about
what flies Gayle and I were using on the steelhead trout. I suggested
he read the October 14, 2009 Recent News and Happenings and corresponding
Fly of the Week postings on my website because the flies we used
were the same type of flies that my son-in-law, Glenn Klinger, used
on our October 1, 2, 3 and 4 steelhead trip. I informed Jason that
I would be using that batch of flies for an upcoming early November
steelhead fishing trip. Jason had just returned from the Erie area
and fished Elk Creek while there. Ironically, Jason was on Elk Creek
while Gayle and I were there but fishing the Mile Creeks on the
East side of Erie. Jason said after the rain event the steelhead
trout were higher upstream on Elk Creek. He took steelhead trout
on a white egg fly with a blood dot and a bead head Prince nymph
combination. More steelhead trout were caught on the Prince nymph,
when used as a dropper, than on the egg fly. Since Jason wanted
to expand his repertoire of flies for an upcoming return steelhead
fishing trip to Elk Creek, I provided him with the tying ingredients
to put him and a few friends in good stead for that upcoming trip
to the Erie area.
***UPDATE
FOR 10/14/09***
The daylight
hours have noticeably decreased in recent weeks and the water temperature
in most streams in PA has dipped to the cool, if not cold, category.
Throw in the arrival of high school, college and professional football
action and, as is common this time of year, most anglers have given
up fly fishing for the season. But hold on. The steelhead, as well
as the noticeable increase in big brown trout, in the Lake Erie
tributaries east of the Erie area have sparked the excitement to
fish for LARGE WILD TROUT!
I need to reemphasize
that the combination of seasonal light variation and the cooler
Lake Erie water temperatures along with recent rain events have
triggered the annual migration of steelhead and a sprinkling of
large brown trout into the East side tributaries. Lake run browns
have been present for many years but not common. According to a
fishing buddy, he has seen brown trout caught over the years. He
speculates this increase is probably the result of stocking in the
tributaries that are approved trout waters and further noted that
the recommended PFBC trout strategy plan provides for the stocking
of brown trout in Lake Erie in an attempt to add diversity to the
tributary fishery, create a near shore springtime fishery and enhance
the offshore summer boat fishery.
My early season
steelhead fishing formula is simple
..in early
October the migrating fish arrive at the mouth of the Lake Erie
East side tributaries and stack up awaiting a significant rain event
that will blow out those shale dams that lake waves have formed
over the summer. These dams, when present, prohibit the upstream
migration of fish. A check of the extended weather forecast, coupled
with good onsite stream conditions from a reliable source and a
flexible fishing schedule (I'm retired) and the stage is set. A
significant rain event occurred at the end of September and another
rain event was forecast to follow in a few days. I was on my way
to the Erie area!
On October 2,
I was on one of the tributary streams east of Erie, fishing during
a steady rain that continued for the remainder of the day and well
into the night. I fished for several hours and left the stream at
noon. I returned at 3:30 p.m. and, in spite of the increased water
flow, I was able to wade to my favorite spots. Three hours later,
with an ever increasing water flow and discoloration of the water,
I felt that crossing the stream to access my vehicle would be hazardous.
I decided to make the circuitous two mile walk through the woods.
This entailed climbing a few cliffs in route to the vehicle, thus
negating the need to wade the stream. I was somewhat tired when
reaching the vehicle but felt I had made the correct decision. Those
of you that have felt the power of water while wading a torrent
flowing stream will understand my reluctance and wisdom in not wading
across at that time.
Returning the
next morning after the rains had subsided, I found the water level
had dropped significantly, a trademark of the tributaries in the
Erie area, and I was able to wade and fish my favorite locations.
Since I knew where the fish were holding prior to the rain event,
the discolored water that resulted from the heavy rains was not
a significant problem. Also, I knew that the fish from the previous
day would have migrated upstream and that the traditional holding
areas would be replenished by fresh fish from the lake. Numerous
hookups and releases followed with the Wooly Bugger as the primary
offering. See Fly of the Week for further information on fly selections.
My thoughts on
early season steelhead fishing in the Erie area tributaries are
as follows: The Lake Erie frontage in the Erie area is known as
the Central Basin and averages 70 feet in depth and provides cool
water, a good combination for lake living trout. The area east of
Erie toward Buffalo is the Eastern Basin and has deeper and cooler
water, some areas as deep as 200 feet. I had received reports of
steelhead trout off the shore and in the Chautauqua Creek in New
York seven to ten days before the fish were spotted at Twenty Mile
Creek, a distance of only about twenty miles apart. It seems reasonable
that the colder water holds the steelhead trout and when the spawning
urges are triggered by light and water conditions the tributaries
around Northeast, PA and Westfield, NY are some of the earliest
to receive and hold fish.
Several of the
fish caught had the raspy suction-cup like scars from the mouth
of sea lampreys. Sea lamprey, an eel like fish, entered Lake Erie
from Lake Ontario via the Welland Canal about 1921. This canal provides
the fish a way of bypassing the Niagara Falls. Some tributaries
in Lake Erie provide spawning and nursery waters for sea lamprey.
The larval sea lamprey may remain in those tributaries for several
years. This could explain why the Wooly Bugger is effective on steelhead
trout and brown trout that migrate into Lake Erie tributaries for
spawning purposes. While in the lake, the steelhead and other fish
are susceptible to mature sea lamprey and their debilitating and
even deadly parasitic ways. The host fish often is killed due to
loss of blood and other body fluids or because of infection in the
resulting wound. Control measures consist of mechanical weirs and
electrical weirs, use of lampricide (costly approach) and sterilization
of the male sea lamprey. Overall, the sea lamprey population has
been greatly reduced.
Steelhead and
brown trout, upon entering the tributaries in preparation for spawning,
do not actively feed. The size of the fish indicates an adequate
storage of life sustaining bio while they are in the tributaries.
So why do we catch these critters on flies like the Wooly Bugger
and egg fly? The egg issue may be the easiest to answer as steelhead
trout eat the eggs of the November spawning brown trout and the
brown trout eat the eggs of the later spawning steelhead trout.
Basically a territorial issue. What about the Wooly Bugger fly?
The easy answer is the larval sea lamprey in the Lake Erie tributaries
are available to the spawning steelhead trout and brown trout and
instinct overrules the biological non feeding necessity and the
survival instinct unleashes the predator instinct embedded in the
fish. However, I cannot locate research that states young sea lampreys
are a significant food source for steelhead and other fish in the
tributaries or in the lakes. The Wooly Bugger simply catches fish!
Thus you have two good flies to present to the spawning fish
.the
Wooly Bugger and the egg fly. Pretty basic but effective fly pattern
choices.